Kinetic isotope effects KIEs inform

Kinetic isotope effects (KIEs) inform on bond vibrational changes between the ground state (GS) and TS of a chemical reaction and remain one of the most powerful experimental techniques for interrogating TS structure. KIEs on enzyme reactions measured by the internal SU5416 of labeled substrates report on kcat/KM (V/K) and include contributions from all steps of the reaction up to and including the first irreversible chemical step (Northrop, 1981). As such, V/K KIEs reflect not only the intrinsic value (the KIE on chemistry alone), but may also contain contributions from isotopically sensitive steps associated with substrate binding, including forward commitment and BIEs (Fig. 2; Ruszczycky & Anderson, 2006). Accordingly, experimental determination of both V/K KIEs and equilibrium BIEs provides information on the relative bonding environments for the substrates of an enzymatic reaction in the free state, the ES complex, and at the TS. Such data inform on the role played by enzymes in modulating the GS and TS structures of the reactants to promote catalysis. Equilibrium BIEs are generally measured under competitive conditions wherein substrates bearing either a light or heavy isotope at the position of interest are mixed and compete for the enzyme binding site. BIE values are then determined by comparing the isotopic ratios of the substrates in the free state to that of the bound state as measured by either liquid scintillation counting (for radioisotopes, e.g., 3H and 14C) or mass spectrometry (for stable isotopes, e.g., 2H, 13C, or 18O). Several experimental approaches have been developed to partition the free and bound substrate states for BIE measurements (vide infra). Common to many of these methods is the passage of an equilibrated mixture of the enzyme and isotopically labeled substrates across a semipermeable membrane with a molecular weight cutoff sufficient to prevent diffusion of the ES complex (i.e., bound fraction) while allowing free passage of the unbound substrate. General considerations for measuring BIEs on enzyme–ligand association include commercial or synthetic access to the requisite isotopically labeled substrates, which are commonly used in stoichiometric excess of the enzyme to promote formation of the ES complex. In addition, high enzyme concentrations (i.e., μM to mM) are often required to provide measurable concentrations of the enzyme-bound substrate fraction. The first isotope effects on binding were reported by Anderson and coworkers (LaReau, Wan, & Anderson, 1989) for the association of [4-2H]NAD+ and [4-3H]NAD+ with lactate dehydrogenase (LDH). In this work, the authors partitioned free and bound substrates by adding a solution of LDH and the [4-H]NAD+ to one side of a dual-chamber dialysis cell and allowing the free substrates to equilibrate across a membrane that was impermeable to the ES complex. The equilibrium dialysis method has been used to measure BIEs for a number of other enzyme systems, including phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (Gawlita, Caldwell, O'Leary, Paneth, & Anderson, 1995) and pyruvate kinase (Gawlita et al., 1995). The primary consideration for this approach is the time required for the system to equilibrate across the dialysis membrane, which demands that both the protein and substrate remain stable at room temperature for an extended period (i.e., 5–8h). Our lab developed an ultrafiltration method for measuring BIEs using a custom-made Plexiglas multiwell apparatus, which was constructed such that a layer of dialysis membrane is sandwiched between two halves of the device to form a division between the superior and inferior aspects of each well (Schramm, 1976). In the ultrafiltration approach, an equilibrated solution of ES complex and free substrate is added to the superior aspect of a well and the pressure of inert gas is used to push approximately half of the solution volume through the dialysis membrane. The ES complex is retained in the superior aspect of the well, while the free substrate passes through the membrane and can be isolated from the inferior aspect of the well. Relative to equilibrium dialysis methods, the ultrafiltration approach generally allows for more rapid partitioning of the free substrate and ES complex (~1h). However, filtration through membranes with low-molecular-weight cutoffs and the use of high protein concentrations can often increase filtration times. In addition, as the force for filtration is supplied by pressurized gas to the superior aspect of the wells, some evaporation of the solution is possible which could require correction of reaction concentrations.